I felt the exact same way for years. Then Bouguereau made me appreciate feet. There was this painting of a little shepherd girl with her foot sticking out from under her dress. The way the pale, wrinkled, pillowy ball of the foot, slightly blackened from dirt was so damn perfect, I thought it was the most impressive part of the painting. Then I realized they were nearly as expressive as hands (yet I still dislike the sight of painted toenails :P).
Hands don't bother me. I really REALLY hate fuckin' feet. I think they're the ugliest part of the human body, bar none.